These questions are ones most judges are likely to encounter.
Was the author's writing style enjoyable?
After reading this book, were you excited about this author and interested in finding other books by her or him?
Did you feel connected emotionally with the hero?
Did you feel emotionally connected with the heroine?
If the plot had secondary characters, did you enjoy them?
Did you like this book's setting?
Would you recommend this book to a friend/family member?
Were there errors or inaccuracies in the story that caught your attention?
If there was a villain, was he/she handled convincingly?
On a scale of 1-10 (poor to wonderful), give this book a rating
Were you anxious to get back to the book when you had to take breaks from reading?
Was the heroine's behavior consistent with her personality?
Was the hero's behavior consistent with his personality?
Specialized Contemporary Questions
Specialized Historical Questions
Were the behaviors of the characters apropriate to the story's time and place?
Did the story appear to be well-researched?
Were the historical elements woven into the story in a smooth, seamless way?
Specialized FF&P Questions
Was the world unique and/or interesting?
Was the author consistent in following the world's rules?
Were the paranormal elements believable?
Readers' Crown Contest Rules
Entry Qualifications and Rules for All Contestants The contest is open to all romance authors published by a non-vanity, non-subsidy publisher/imprint/line, in both traditional print and electronic publishing.
Entrants may designate a second category for the work in the event the first-choice category does not receive the required number of entries to be judged or the category is full when the author's entry is received.
Entrants must indicate the sensuality level of their book. The choices are Mild, Hot, or Blazing. Every effort will be made to match entries with judges who accept works with the indicated sensuality level.
There is no limit to the number of eligible books/manuscripts that may be entered for each author in each category, although each category has an upper limit of 150 entries. Authors may enter any book in multiple categories if so desired (e.g., a book may be entered in the Paranormal category, the Best First Book category, and the Erotic Romance category.) Except for Best First Book, a separate entry form, fee, and 5 books are required for each category entered.
Published works currently available exclusively in electronic formats shall be printed on standard 8.5” X 11” white paper, bound, and mailed with the entry form and fees to the appropriate coordinator by the contest deadline. Five printed copies of each work are required to be eligible. Electronic copies will not be accepted. The bound work must include the publisher's copyright page. If the work is available in Print on Demand (POD) format, that is what must be submitted.
NO books/works will be returned except when the category’s minimum entry threshold is not met or the category’s threshold is exceeded (or categories', if the entrant indicated a second choice on the registration form).
If any category has fewer than 20 entries (defined as all copies of required work to be judged, not just the entry form) received by the deadline, the category shall not be judged. At such a time, an entrant will be placed in an alternate category if one was indicated on the registration form. If an alternate category was not indicated, the entry forms and fees shall be returned to the entrant. No entry shall be allowed to change categories except in the case of category cancellation. Each category has a limit of 150 entries.
All contest entries and appropriate fees must be received by Romance Conventions, Inc., no later than 11:59 p.m. Mountain Time, January 31, 2010. Any items received after January 31st will result in disqualification. No books will be returned and no refunds will be given to entrants who fail to meet the deadline.
If a check is returned or a credit card charge denied, the replacement money, plus a $25 processing fee, must be in the Romance Conventions, Inc., office by February 7, 2010, or the entrant shall be disqualified and books forfeited.
Readers’ Crown™ Contest coordinators will send a confirmation letter or e-mail to all entrants and/or nominators.
Finalists shall be notified by phone, and then by an Official Letter of Notification sent by the RomCon™ Office via 2-day registered mail.
The complete list of finalists will be made public and posted on our website no later than April 30, 2010, at 11:59 p.m. Mountain Time.
Neither employees of Romance Conventions, Inc., nor members of their immediate families shall be eligible to enter the Readers’ Crown™ contest.
All deadlines are final.
Readers’ Crown™ non-finalists who so mark their entry forms shall be sent their preliminary-round score totals after the end of the preliminary round. Finalists will receive their scores after the conclusion of the contest.
Individual scores will not be reported or returned to anyone other than the author(s) of each entry.
If any finalist is disqualified for any reason, no other entrant shall move up to fill a vacant spot.
Other Contest Rules Books entered in the 2010 Readers’ Crown™ contest must:
Have an original copyright date (printed on the copyright page) or a first printing date or a first North American printing date of 2009. NOTE: The entry may have previously been published in electronic format under a different ISBN.
Not have been previously entered.
Be produced by a non-subsidy, non-vanity publisher in either electronic or print book format.
Meet the requirements for the category in which it was entered.
Be an original work of romantic fiction.
Decisions of the judges are final.
Finalists may be asked to submit a high-resolution image file.
Five copies of the book are required. Bound copies of the work being entered will only be accepted for works published only in electronic format.
In the event that duplicate entries for the same book are received, the first nomination shall be the official entry and the subsequent entries and fees will be returned. However, if the author is one of the nominators, the author’s choice of category (and alternate if applicable) will prevail.
A collection of novels/novellas is not one entry; rather, each work must be entered separately and five copies of the book must be submitted for each entry. The appropriate fee shall be paid for each entry.
All Readers’ Crown™ entrants are required to acknowledge and accept these rules via the electronic entry form.
Romance Conventions, Inc., may request 2 additional books from the author if needed for discrepancy judging.
The love triangle, naturally I’m speaking of one woman torn between two men. We’ve all been there … at least vicariously. Just think of it, how wonderful -- and how horrible -- it would be to have two admirable, deserving men vying for your love? How would you choose? Would it be clear cut? Would you always have a niggling of regret?
I’ve been thinking of this a lot lately. Especially with the whole “Team Edward vs. Team Jacob” thing going on with the Twilight series. As with most fictional love triangles, the two camps are deeply entrenched in their conviction that the heroine choose their hero. And, of course, in romance novels the choice must be made.
Here are a few of my picks on the fictional love triangle scoreboard:
True Blood: Okay, this isn’t really a triangle because Sookie seems to hate Eric, but man, I’m sorta rooting for the guy – not that I have anything against Bill.
Janet Evanovich’s Stephanie Plum series: Ranger or Joe? I’m probably in the minority here, but I’m all for Joe. I think it must be because of my penchant for Beta heroes.
Phantom of the Opera (Gerard Butler movie version, of course). Even after he shows his really bad side, my heart’s still with the Phantom. Could it be because of my Gerard Butler fascination? Perhaps, because it goes against my Beta hero thing.
The Road Home, by yours truly: Clay, Lily and Peter. Well, I’m not going to reveal that one, because if you haven’t read it, you’ll have no reason to do so.
Camelot: King Arthur, Guinevere, Sir Lancelot. Toughie. I’m going to go with Arthur on this one.
“Sweet Home Alabama”: That’s a no brainer. (Oops, hope I didn’t offend any Patrick Dempsy fans!)
Tristan, Isolde, King Mark: Tristan all the way. Sorry Mark.
“Casablanca”: Rick, Ilsa, Victor. To heck with Beta heroes, Rick all the way here.
That leads me to heroes and why we love them. I know it’s like real life, everyone sees a person differently. But for the most part, romantic fiction heroes are nearly universal in their appeal to women. Writers create men as we’d like them to be, strong, yet caring; tough and protective, yet encouraging a heroine’s personal growth; and being hot doesn’t hurt either. In essence, the hero has to have something that completes the heroine, something that no one else can give for us to really love them.
Now for my admission: I’ve fallen a little in love with every one of the heroes I’ve created. Maybe it’s because he was my “first born,” but Will Scott from Back Roads is at the top of my list. I suppose that’s like choosing a favorite child and I just shouldn’t do it, but in Will’s case I’m making an exception. Luke from Magnolia Sky has been in a tie for second place with Nate from Seeing Red but now it’s going three-way with Jason from my upcoming January release, Sleep No More. Oh, but I do so love Clay and Dean and Eric and Mick and Gabe, too. I do, I really do.
I suppose I’m caught in an ever-increasing love polygon. Each new hero carves out a place in my heart all his own, just like King Arthur and Sir Lancelot did in Guinevere’s.
Let’s hear a little about your favorite heroes and why you love them.
Posted by Susan Crandall on 2009-12-10 at 12:40:35 pm:
Thanks so much to everyone! Love, love, love seeing everyone's favorite heroes. And thanks even more to those of you who are reading my heroes!
Good point about not letting a good guy who loses in a triangle go without meeting the love of his life in the next book. I'm all about that.
Posted by Tiffany James on 2009-12-09 at 21:33:21 pm:
Hey, Susan, just wanted to stop back by once more and thank you for spending the day at RomCon! I hope you'll visit again soon ~ Tiffany
Posted by Donna S on 2009-12-09 at 20:32:38 pm:
Great heroes! I dont know if its possible to top Mr Darcy though in Pride and Prejudice. He did so much for her while thinking she hated him. Aww.
Posted by Lisa G on 2009-12-09 at 16:34:38 pm:
I love all you points...Great post.
Posted by Quilt Lady on 2009-12-09 at 14:03:37 pm:
I guess one of my favorite heros whould have to be Harry Pye for Elizabeth Holt's Leopard Prince and also Rhett Butler for GWTW. I loved both of the heros.
Posted by Katrina C on 2009-12-09 at 11:53:12 am:
I love Beta heroes, too, Susan. I've known Alpha males in my life, and they stop seeming romantic very quickly! So if I ever have a choice of hero to root for, it's the tender man all the way.
Posted by Kara C on 2009-12-09 at 10:38:55 am:
I love a hero with a past - the alpha who thinks he's going to save the heroine only to discover he needs a little saving himself!
BTW, I LOVED Seeing Red! Great, great book. And although I like Joe, I definitely will have to vote for Ranger! lol
Have a great day.
Posted by Tiffany James on 2009-12-09 at 10:07:49 am:
Oooh, good point, Michele! ~ Tiffany
Posted by Michele Chambers on 2009-12-09 at 08:13:33 am:
I have read the entire Sookie Stackhouse series. I'm all for Eric. Yum. He's more dangerous, and more considerate than Bill. Powerful combination. My Shelfari group is mostly on Joe's side over Ranger. But when I need a great movie fix I watch Pride and Prejudice. Love Mr. Darcy. I really enjoy the love triangles in romance novels. My only rule for an author is when a really great guy doesn't get the girl - he gets his own book and a heroine that is even better for him later! You can break the poor guy's heart, but you have to fix it later on. :)
Posted by Tiffany James on 2009-12-09 at 07:58:06 am:
Hi, Susan! Welcome to RomCon! Ah, favorite heroes - one of my favorite topics! :0) I agree with Emmanuelle, Malone from Catch of the Day was great. I love quiet, silent types. Of course, I also like alpha males and more sensitive heroes...oh, heck! I love them all! I love Devereux from Lynda Hilburn's Vampire Shrink series. An 800 year old vampire with an enticing mix of chivalry and knowledge of the modern world. The Wilder Brothers from Jill Shalvis's series...I could go on and on! I just started Pitch Black, and I'm starting to take a shine to Gabe Wyatt, too. Thanks for joining us today, Susan! ~ Tiffany
Posted by Susan Crandall on 2009-12-09 at 07:50:10 am:
Good list, Emmanuelle! Glad to see there' s another Joe fan out there.
Linda, kudos on the Bruce Willis suggestion. Can't get more heroic than that. When I watched that movie, I kept hoping for "the miracle save." Choked me up when it didn't come.
Had another thought on Hawkeye ... he was willing to give up his life, but Duncan actaually did it. Wonder why we didn't fall for Duncan like we did Hawkeye?
Posted by Emmanuelle on 2009-12-09 at 02:26:12 am:
I sooooo agree with you on Joe in the Plum series. I really love this guy and still can't understand why Stephanie would go for a Ranger when she has a delicious Joe at home !! See, you're not alone ;-)
As for my favorite heroes... well, most of SEP's heroes are on my list, Calvin from Bet Me, Malone from Catch of the Day, Sebastian from the Devil In Winter or Lucian from Lord a Scoundrel. There are so many great heroes out there... can't wait to read yours !!
Posted by Linda Henderson on 2009-12-08 at 23:53:59 pm:
I think the first movie hero that comes to my mind is Bruce Willis in Armegedon. He gives up his life to save the earth and all humanity. You can't help but think of him as a hero in this movie. I also enjoyed the Last Of The Mohicans. I listen to the soundtrack every now and then.
Posted by Susan Crandall on 2009-12-08 at 21:24:31 pm:
Oh, how could I have forgotten Hawkeye (movie version of course, book, not so much)? I think I'll go watch that DVD right now.
I just thought of Sookie Stackhouse again, she's really in more of a love quadrangle, I forgot to mention poor Sam.
Posted by librarypat on 2009-12-08 at 21:10:58 pm:
My favorite is Daniel "Hawkeye" in Last Of The Mohicans. He is strong, some one you can count on when it counts, and rugged. When he cares, he cares deeply and will do anything for the woman he loves.